Sandwich!

I'm hungry for an amazing sandwich. Give me a recommendation and where to get it. Can be in or near Long Valley.

No Avatar Chris
July 1st

· link · flag

Schooley's Mtn General Store has AWESOME paninis!!

No Avatar gab942
July 1st

link · flag

Wow, I never knew that they had panini at Schooley's Mtn. Store. Will have to check that out.

Gravatar for Calico696 Calico696 Message Calico696
July 1st

link · flag

Brian's in Hackettstown has the best roast beef ever. Try a sandwich with horseradish dressing on the side. Actually, I should post this on the "addictions" thread on HL.

Gravatar for cbel cbel Message cbel
July 2nd

link · flag

Black River General Store in Pottersville! Roasts their own roast beef, huge italian subs with amazing peppers and in the winter they make wonderful soups with their own stock (who does that anymore!). Bread in from NY every day!

If you don't know where Pottersville is, the back way, which is fun to take this time of year, is Old Farmers Road to left onto Black River road (winds along the river) to the end in Pottersville, make a left and store is on the right!

Pottersville is in 3 counties, Morris, Somerset and Hunterdon, a great little town!

Enjoy!

Gravatar for LDavis LDavis Message LDavis
July 12th

link · flag

Not only are the Sandwiches fresh at the Black river General Store, they are very generous with the portions of cold cuts on the sanwich. I will be trying the Roast Beef, thanks for the tip.
Does the Black River General Store Cater parties too?

By the way, did you know that every Christmas the town of Pottersville is magically transformed in Bedford Falls? You must drive through Pottersville at Christmas time and see it for yourself.

Gravatar for Billy Smith Billy Smith Message Billy Smith
July 13th

link · flag

Oldwick General Store is a classic

Gravatar for Kathy Kathy Message Kathy
July 22nd

link · flag

Piggys on RT 57 cuts everything fresh. It was very good

No Avatar BBD
1 week ago

link · flag

Once Upon a Table on Main St in Chester has great sandwiches. 2 of my faves: black forest ham with brie on pumpernickel and turkey with walnuts, granny smith apple slices, cranberry relish and havarti on some kind of yummy bread. Oh forgot about another fave- their proscuitto with buffalo mozz on foccacia....my mouth is watering. They have great chicken sandwiches,too. The sandwiches are HUGE- each can serve 2 people.

No Avatar skeeter
7 days ago

link · flag

Leave a Reply

To comment on this topic, fill out the form below. If you would like to comment directly to one person, you may click on the envelope next to the posters name if they provided an email address.

Re: Sandwich!
Display Name (Required)
Email (Hidden, Gravatar)
Your Web Site
By pressing Submit Comment, you are agreeing to the terms and conditions.